Date of Fucking: Sometime Before 2012. 
Pre-Fuck: That Movie Sleepover.
Post-Fuck: Got Engaged to Emma Roberts, Who Beat Him Up.

I heard that you like the bad girls honey, is that true? Before dating Lindsay Lohan Lite Emma Roberts, Evan reportedly got with Lindsay Lohan herself. No one's really sure when this happened, but Peters got with Roberts in 2012, so we're guessing sometime before that. Was it perhaps right after American Horror Story premiered? Because that seems to be the time when everyone collectively agreed that Evan Peters was suddenly very, very hot. Gone were his Sleepover days. LiLo snatched him right up.