10. "The Eye Of The Beholder"
We hate to break it to you, but Minka Kelly is busted—at least by the standards of the society depicted in this freaky second season episode. When the story opens, we come face to bandaged face with Janet Tyler (Donna Douglas), a woman who's undergone more plastic surgery than Heidi Montag in efforts to look "normal" like everyone else. As the tale progresses, it becomes harder and harder to stand the suspense. How butterfaced could this patient possibly be? What unspeakable deformities lay beneath those bandages? Well, you might be underwhelmed by Janet's big reveal—but as for the other citizens around her...that's a whole other story.