Date: 12/21/2003
Game and Outcome: Jacksonville Jaguars 20, New Orleans Saints 19
The Saints were in the middle of a Wild Card race against the Cowboys and the Seahawks when John Carney did the unthinkable. He shattered the hopes and dreams of an entire state immediately following one of the greatest-last second touchdowns in history. The Saints radio play-by-play man, Jim Henderson sounded like he'd just seen his dog shot. And rightfully so, Carney's one of the greatest kickers of all time. What a way to lose a game.

*Not a field goal, yes. That's actually the only reason this isn't No. 1.