4. Mick Foley

Era: Late '90s to 2000s

If Mick Foley was your father, you would be mortified by how he dressed. "Really Dad? You're gonna wear blue sweat pants and a red flannel? Never drop me off again!" As any of his wrestling personalities, though (like Dude Love or Mankind), the hardcore legend Mick was cool in spite of himself. He may be even more common looking than Dusty Rhodes (thanks to the disgusting scars that cover Dusty's poor forehead). Then again Mick is missing an ear. -PR