Date: 9/24/2012
Game: Green Bay Packers @ Seattle Seahawks

OK, this game was ugly way before the final possession (Cedric Benson was a "top performer" with 45 yards) but the final call of the game took it to the next level. When super stars from other leagues are expressing their frustration and one player on the losing team compares it to someone defecating on painting, you know it's bad.