There was a painting of Alex Rodriguez as a centaur that everyone thought hung in his house.

For years we chuckled about ARod's centaur painting because it added so much to our perception of him as a player and as a man. It wasn't until December of last year that he revealed that the painting was an unfounded rumor. Maybe he was just saying that to save face. We still want to believe that it hangs in his living room!

images via