Since the New York Giants won their second Super Bowl in four years in 2011, it hasn’t been the greatest of times for two-time Super Bowl MVP Eli Manning. In the years following, Eli has never led Big Blue to more than nine wins in a season, and he recently ended his worst yearas far as wins and losses are concernedsince taking over as the full-time starter in 2005.

In fact, aside from winning Super Bowl XLII and XLVI, Manning has been pretty average throughout his career. He has a career completion percentage of 59.0 has thrown 259 touchdowns against 185 interceptions, and holds a regular season record of 91-76.

However, those two Super Bowl victories cannot be ignored. There are just 11 quarterbacks in NFL history with the distinction of two or more Super Bowl victories, and Elisha Nelson Manning is one of them. And while he’s been far from the most dominant quarterback over the last 10 years or so, he has been one of the most durable. Eli currently holds the third-longest NFL quarterback consecutive start streak of all-time with 178 straight games, regular season and playoffs combined. He is the active leader ahead of Phillip Rivers.

With the last name Manning and all those games played, there have been a whole lot of memorable facial expressions. Today Eli Manning turns 34, and in celebration of the mild-mannered quarterback’s birthday, we’ve decided to round up those expressions and have some fun. From the shrug to utter dismay, these are the Faces You Use While Arguing With Your Girlfriend, According to Eli Manning.