Stats before bust year: 15 G, 1,309 YDS, 17 TDS
Bust year stats: 12 G, 840 YDS, 2 TDS
Reason(s) for bust: Injuries, bad team
The No. 1 player on many draft boards going into the 2012 season, LeSean McCoy had owners buzzing about his big-play ability between the tackles and on check-downs. He suffered on a disappointing Eagles "Dream Team," featuring in just 12 games before going down with an injury in November. Following up a 17 rushing TD campaign with just two rushing TDs in 12 games is a surefire way to earn bust status.