Headline: Rob Wiethoff
Character: John Marston
Game: Red Dead Redemption

Rob Wiethoff's performance of outlaw turned family hero John Marston probably left you in tears. (Or almost left you in tears.) The road to redemption is a challenge for Marston as he revisits a past life he hoped to escape, in order to save his family. Through Wiethoff we see Marston grow into a man whose life is unfortunately cut too short. That last five-plus minutes of Redemption will forever stick with us, Wiethoff ending his performance with undeniable bravado.