Most Dominant Year: 2008

Yes, everyone. That Vince Young. Sure, he walked out on his team last season, and he's never close the likes of Aaron Rodgers and Tom Brady. But the Madden gods have always loved VY's speed, and he's typically one of the game's fastest signal-callers. In the right hands, that makes for a devastatingly dangerous online QB. Young would rank even higher on this list if he'd played in Madden before 2005, when EA did its best to remove some of the running QB advantage.