Wrestler: Dolph Ziggler
Dolph Ziggler sells moves as well as anybody in the WWE (which prevents this compilation of his best Zig Zags from looking terrible). In fact, all that effort makes this move looks like it hurts him more than his competition. Try it on an unsuspecting neighbor and we're sure it'd hurt like hell, but as a way to end a drawn out battle? There's way too many better finishers out there.