2. Wide Right!

What: Super Bowl XXV vs. Buffalo Bills
Date: 1/27/1991

We're not sure what's more amazing: That Scott Norwood missed a 47-yard field goal attempt as time expired to give the Giants the first and only one-point victory in NFL history—or that the G-Men won a Super Bowl with career backup QB Jeff Hostetler running the team. Either way, the "Wide Right Game" as it's now known was full of surprises, so it's only right that it ended the way it did.