9. The Catch After "The Catch"

What: Super Bowl XLII vs. New England Patriots
Date: 2/3/2008

Everyone remembers the other "catch" in this game. Spoiler alert: That one is much, much higher on this list. But this was the moment that sealed the game for the Giants and essentially guaranteed that they'd be leaving Arizona with their seventh NFL title and their first since 1990. And, is it just us or did it look like Plaxico Burress was Tebowing in the end zone after he caught the game-winning touchdown from Eli Manning? Well played, Plax. In '08, you were the man, homie.