Shooter: Derek Fisher
Game: Game 5, 2004 Western Conference Semifinals
Tim Duncan had just made a running 18-footer over Shaq to give the Spurs the lead in Game 5 and presumably the series. Despite the additions of Gary Payton and Karl Malone, for the second straight year the Spurs were ready to eliminate La Lakers. But in all the celebration, no one noticed he'd make a mistake. It's impossible to even count to 0.4 seconds, but that's all it took for Derek Fisher to snatch away the victory. Lesson learned, Timmy?