Played By: Chad Michael Murray and Sophia Bush

Before the love triangle between Lucas, Peyton and Brooke became a tough call—i.e. Brooke actually became an endearing character—fans who shipped Lucas and Peyton were enraged at the idea of her best friend swooping in for her man. And it's not like Brooke tried to make it easy on the audience to like her—she hid in Lucas' car and stripped down just to get his attention.