Tara Reid's Conquests: Reid easily has the most decorated dating life of any of her American Pie cohorts. In the past, she has been linked to Fred Durst, Jeremy Shockey, Ashton Kutcher, and Tom Brady, and she once had a high-profile engagement to semi-celeb Carson Daly before it fizzled. More recently, Reid was reportedly married to a Bulgarian financier named Zack Kehayov, but it turns out that the marriage was never legal in the first place. Oops.
Alyson Hannigan's Marital Bliss: Buffy The Vampire Slayer actor Alexis Denisof is one lucky man, being that he locked Alyson Hannigan down for life in 2003. Not only is she sexy, in a geeky sort of way, but she also seems to be the most normal of the female Pie crew. The couple is currently expecting their second child.
Who Needs Pies Anyway?: After a brief fling with co-star Tara Reid, Jason Biggs finally settled down with actress/writer Jenny Mollen. Despite neither of them qualifying for Hollywood's A-list, this couple does seem to be one of the more normal ones in Hollywood. Well, besides the whole hooker thing.
How Tom Cruise Stole Chris Klein's Girl: Without a doubt, the most talked-about hook-up of the entire American Pie cast was Chris Klein’s five-year relationship with Katie Holmes. The couple even got engaged in 2003, but called it off two short years later. Not too long after, Holmes started dating Tom Cruise, who she eventually married. Score one for Scientology.