11. Pop Tart Sushi

Served At: Pop-Tarts World Café (Recently Closed)
Address: 128 West 42nd St., New York
Website: poptartsworld.com

Though the Pop-Tarts World franchise in NYC's Times Square was pretty much on death watch from day one, we didn't think they'd shutter quite so soon. Among our biggest regrets? Not getting over there in time to sample their acid trip of a sushi dish. Sure, it might look pretty questionable, but let's be real; marshmallow, Fruit Roll-Ups, and mashed up Pop-Tart probably aren't the worst things you've consumed together in one sitting.