Event: Super Bowl XLII
Date: 2/3/2008 

David Tyree's miracle catch in Super Bowl XLII is one of the best plays in NFL history and helped the Giants complete the greatest upset in modern sports history. But if you close your eyes and turn up the sound, you'd think it's a simple inside slant for a first down. Unless Joe was sipping prescription strength cough syrup in the booth, there's absolutely no excuse for this kind of hollow emotion. Unless, of course, you have no emotions. Gus Johnson would've went clinically insane if he were on the call.