Netflix’s mockumentary American Vandal is back for another season, and this time, the show trails co-creators and documentarians Peter Maldonado and Sam Ecklund as they take on a new case at a premiere Catholic school: someone named the Turd Burglar has played a massive poop-related prank on the school, and Maldonado and Ecklund have been tasked with uncovering the mischief maker.

In American Vandal's inaugural season last year, the two investigators went to a private school, where they were looking into who spraypainted phalluses on the cars of teachers and faculty members.

The next season of American Vandal will be available to stream on Friday, Sept. 14.