Year: 2000
Team: Tampa Bay Buccaneers
Overall Rating: 100

It's somewhat unorthodox to include a fullback on this list, given how underused they've become in recent years, but anyone who played Madden 2000 knew that handing Mike Alstott the ball was the way to go when faced with a goal-line situation. Plays at the one-yard line are always sort've a rock-paper-scissors game, but Mike Alstott was basically dynamite. And dynamite wins. Every. Single. Time.