Many aughties reality shows sought to put together the perfect singing group, and even Making the Band’s first season was awesomely embarrassing—remember O-Town? The third season saw the formation of poor man’s Pussycat Dolls, Danity Kane. As ridiculous as they may be, don’t forget that they actually not one but two #1 albums.

They split up in 2009, and member Aubrey O’Day had her own trash-tastic show on Oxygen and even finished third on The Celebrity Apprentice 5. She supposedly has a new album coming out, but how about getting the old band back together? Maybe they could even add Chris Crocker to the lineup.