If you think about it, it’s kind of surprising that we have yet to catch one of the characters (most likely Frank—or perhaps a naive Charlie) mid-ass paddling or fisting. The writers haven’t been shy about introducing the gangs to orgies, glory holes, and mother-fucking (literally), among other things.

Moreover, S&M almost seems kinda mainstream these days, popping up in Top 40 songs and primetime ABC shows. But maybe that’s where the problem lies. Could stuffing a ball-gagged Danny DeVito into a leather getup be too obvious a choice for the show’s plot weavers? We guess we’ll find out this season.