Nothing will ever top the Halloween magic that was Jay Z, Beyoncé and Blue Ivy dressed as Coming to America characters, but Jimmy Fallon certainly gave it his best shot. The Tonight Show host teamed up with Alanis Morissette and Meghan Trainor to form the Jagged Little Chicks, which required them to perform in bright yellow feather costumes while clucking “Ironic” in its entirety.

If you were alive at any point in the ‘90s, you’ve probably heard the song before but never like this. And though it might seem like a difficult task, the quartet remained perfectly on beat and delivered a surprisingly understandable performance. Travel back to the decade of jelly sandals and baggy jeans, and check out the above video.