If you watched Are You Afraid of the Dark? in its first run, you probably remember the show as the late-night dose of horror that topped off a night of cartoon comedy on SNICK. I personally still have chilling images from the show seared in my brain, which have stuck with me (and terrified me) since childhood.

Now we're all a little bit older, and hopefully a little bit wiser. So, it's time to look back at the series with fresh eyes. Various sites have put together lists of the most terrifying episodes. So, let's start with their suggestions and answer the question we've been wondering about for years: Was Are You Afraid of the Dark? Actually Scary (Or Were You Just a P***y)?