Producer: Mike Posner & Benny Blanco
Complex says: This song is the centerpiece of the album. While all the songs before it are fun, playful, and mostly involve getting some action, all the songs after this one are much darker and gloomier. As you may have guessed, the song is about a girl Mike wanted to wife until she cheated on him. The hook is absolutely epic: "I should have cheated on you/Nobody told me I was dating a whore." But it gets better! Towards the end of the song, Mike gives a classic shout-out a la the author's note in the film, 500 Days of Summer: "Caroline Stevens, this song is for you."