4. Smokin' Jay Cutler
Meme Origin: The ever-scowling Jay Cutler needs an image makeover.
Everyone who watches the NFL knows that Jay Cutler gives off a vibe that could, at best, be described as "surly." Give him credit: nobody appears to have more disdain for his teammates, city, and fans than Cutler. How could he seem anymore apathetic, one might ask? Just add a cigarette! Smokin' Jay Cutler has become one of the great Tumblr accounts in recent memory, and has finally given the quarterback a nickname that will stick.