Character: Aquaman
Game: Aquaman: Battle for Atlantis (2003)

This deservedly maligned GameCube title almost ruined Aquaman for a generation of DC fans. Sporting his rugged underwater biker look from the early '90s, Aquaman looks less like the king of Atlantis and more like a rough trade trick looking for a john. Outfit aside, Aquaman has one of the most underused power-sets in all of the DC Universe, the telepathic manipulation of sea creatures, which is quite impressive when you think about how much of this planet is under water. It makes up for his fishy fashion choices. Almost.