19. Compost Cookies

Served At: Momofuku Milk Bar (NYC)
Address: Multiple Locations (Check Website)
Website: momofuku.com

While the pretzel, potato chip, chocolate and butterscotch chip, and coffee-packed baked goods may sound like something someone dug out of the garbage disposal and stuck in an oven, critics swear by Momofuku Milk Bar founder David Chang's heady treats, which have also earned him much love from the acclaimed James Beard Foundation.