When: 2004
What, you thought Jeter was gonna be monogamous? Rumors about Jeter and the Honey starlet began circulating after the two were spotted at Hollywood's Spider Club in LA. There was no official word of the breakup but when Jeter was spotted with steady chick Vanessa Minnillo at a Knick game that November, the press knew it was over. Months later, rumors spread that the couple split because Jeter gave Alba herpes. Yikes!
Smash Probability: