Neighborhood: Greenwich Village
Address: 7 Carmine St.

Situated within easy walking distance of the Cage, this small pizza joint in the Village has catered to random city slickers, tourists, NYU students, and celebrities for ages. It's standing room mostly, with a few stools for good measure. But don't fret: The turnover rate for a plain pie is every 10 minutes. If it's your first time, you must try the plain slice. It's a wonder, with thin crust, tasty sauce, and the perfect amount of cheese. There are other options, but first remind yourself how good a regular slice can be.