Most Dominant Year: 2006

The Colts QB doesn't have that one standout characteristic that makes him a video game force, which is just fine, because he's still ultra-consistent and ultra-skilled. Manning can make all the throws, and he brings high Awareness ratings every year. Oddly, he's never been on the cover of the game, despite being one of the most well-known faces of the NFL. Then again, maybe he's just trying to avoid that curse.