9. Dontrelle Willis

MLB Slugfest (Xbox/PS2, 2006)
Think of Willis as baseball’s version of Peyton Hillis: He had a cool nickname (“The D-Train”), was a fan favorite for his quirky windup, and was coming off a career 22-10 year, so the folks at Midway couldn’t help tossing Willis onto their box. They were probably as surprised as everyone else when Willis stumbled in 2006...and then proceeded to fall apart for the rest of his career. At least Willis wasn’t alone on the Slugfest box front; alongside the likes of Manny Ramirez, Pedro Martinez, Albert Pujols, Vlad Guerrero, and Jason Giambi, nobody even noticed him.