Buy It Now: Timex Weekender Watch, $39

You aren't quite ready to join the Rollie gang, but you don't want to settle for some cereal-box-prize looking-ass watch, either. You stroll over to J. Crew because the Timex seems perfect and their $150 tag. Little did you know that Walmart has a crazy nice Weekender with the grey/orange strap for only $38. Hope you kept your receipt.