Date: 1/15/1967
Super Bowl: I
Matchup: Packers vs. Chiefs
Location: Los Angeles
Watch it here 

Few (if any) of our readers will be old enough to remember Super Bowl I, but the very first touchdown in the game's history was also one of its best. Packers backup receiver Max McGee, who only had four receptions all season, made a spectacular one-handed grab for a 37-yard touchdown to give his team an early lead. McGee would finish the game with seven receptions for 138 yards and two touchdowns, but lost out on the MVP award to his teammate Bart Starr.