23. "How Come You Don't Call Me" (2001)

Producer: Alicia Keys, Kerry "Krucial" Brothers
Album: Songs in A Minor

Somehow, someway, Keys was able to turn one of the most nagging questions in relationship history—originally a Prince song—into an incredibly soulful ballad of romantic desire. It was the third and last single from her debut album, leaving a lasting impression of how incredibly talented Keys is on her new fan base.