Wifey Of: AJ Feeley, St. Louis Rams (NFL)
Occupation: Professional Soccer Player, Model

Mitts' modeling career got started with the dubious honor of being named Playboy's "Sexiest Woman of the WUSA," an award for which the competition was not exactly tough. The recognition got slightly more legitimate in 2004, though, when she was voted ESPN's "Hottest Female Athlete" by the fans. She reached the height of her modeling fame in 2005, posing for the Sports Illustrated Swimsuit Issue among the likes of Marisa Miller and Petra Nemcova.

Mitts maintained a long, tumultuous relationship with NFL quarterback A.J. Feeley dating back to 2002, and the duo officially married in 2010.