Wifey Of: Sean Avery, New York Rangers (NHL), Dion Phaneuf, Calgary Flames (NHL)
Cuthbert will forever be a favorite of twentysomething males everywhere after her turn as a porn star with a heart of gold in the comedy, The Girl Next Door. In her spare time, the Canadian-born actress also dates hockey players. She first dated the outspoken Sean Avery, then moved on to Toronto Maple Leafs captain Dion Phaneuf (but not before Avery got in a very public dig at Phaneuf where he referred to Cuthbert as his "sloppy seconds"). If the comment was meant to make any sort of impact on the relationship, it didn't; Avery got suspended and is now out of the league, and the happy couple got engaged this past September.