When The Blair Witch Project came out in 1999, it changed the face of horror films. Terrified audiences from across the nation were all asking the same question: Wait…did this really happen?

Now, the legacy of the first film is explored in the haunting new sequel Blair Witch. The legend of Blair Witch returns with James, who, after discovering a video of what he believes to be his missing sister, ventures into the woods with a group of friends in an attempt to uncover the mysteries around her disappearance.

From horror maestros Adam Wingard and Simon Barrett, the new Blair Witch chapter is more terrifying than ever. You can catch it in theaters September 16th, but be sure to check out the chilling new trailer now by clicking on the video above.

This fall, evil has a very familiar name.