Most memorable horror movie: Shark Night 3D (2011)

Number of horror movies she starred in: 4

Though her career was kicked off by co-starring in family films like Liar Liar and Durango Kids, this captivating California girl starred in 3 horror flicks in 2011 alone; The Innkeepers, Enter Nowhere and Shark Night 3D. Maybe Paxton needs to revisit her comedic roots.