DOOM 3 (2004)
BEFORE RELEASE: "OMG did you see the screenshots they just released for Doom 3? My eyes just came!"
AFTER RELEASE: "Wait. I’ve been playing for like an hour and I’m BORED now. Even the graphics aren’t saving this one. And did that demon just pop out of a locker? No, seriously—dude was SITTING inside of a locker, WAITING for me to walk into the room. The fuck was he doing in there this whole time?"