Sport Played: NHL
Year: 2008
Crime: Took a woman's purse and cell phone from a restaurant in Tampa, Fla.

NHL rookies don't make the most money in the world. But they do make more—way more—than the average Joe. So people were puzzled when they heard that O'Byrne, who was a rookie with the Canadiens at the time, had stolen a purse and a cell phone from a woman at a restaurant during a team dinner. It's worth noting that, on that particular night, O'Byrne and his fellow rookies were asked to foot the bill for the dinner, which might explain why he was strapped for cash. But still, you're an NHL player, dude! Some poor woman's purse is not your personal ATM.