Charlie Day is good at a lot of things. He’s very funny in both It’s Always Sunny in Philadelphia and Horrible Bosses. He is an excellent college commencement speaker. He’s a conscientious next door neighbor.

One thing he is not good at, however, is guessing movie titles.

He appeared on The Tonight Show and tried to play host Jimmy Fallon’s “Five Second Summaries,” and his knowledge of children’s movies left something to be desired. You can kind of forgive not knowing Big Hero 6, but Pinocchio? Come on, man.

And the high five attempt, while not Charlie’s fault, was equally pathetic. Not this duo’s best work.

[via Vulture]