Cover Star: Brett Favre (No Crocs)
Year: 2008

You could play it on an iPhone! It had Impact Plays! Madden Tests that tailored the game's difficulty to your skill level! (Or lack thereof!) This one gets points off because as per the conditions of the karmic chupacabra that is the Madden Curse, it eventually caused Brett Favre to send a picture of his flaccid penis to a woman while he was wearing Crocs. Peace to the Hologram John Madden; that would prove oddly prophetic.