Sure, Pretty Little Liars sounds like it has a plot-line designed for a 12-year-old, but the show's most enjoyable element is the fact that nothing is as it appears to be. Parents could be criminal accomplices, dead bodies could get dug up outside seemingly perfect suburban homes, and friendly neighborhood cops are quite possibly bitter stalkers.

Imagine a contemporary, live-action game of Clue, with undeniably gorgeous suspects, that doesn’t quite let you win just when you think you have all the hints you need to unmask the murderer.