Final Level: The Thief
Why It Sucked: Moral choices in games can definitely be hit or miss, and the choice at the end of Fable 2 has miss written all over it. You're supposed to choose between a bunch of money, resurrecting your family and beloved dog, or resurrecting the other, like, millions of people who've been killed along the way.
How We Would End It: This choice is completely ridiculous. Why the hell would one option resurrect everyone except your loved ones? Cosmic trolling?