The success of David Fincher's The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo greatly hinged one thing—who would play Lisbeth Salander? Luckily for Fincher, relative unknown Rooney Mara's fearless performance has plucked her out of obsucirty and made her, and the film, a success.

But before Mara's star power was confirmed, Fincher was considering a number of actreses to take on the role, perhaps none as intriguing as Scarlett Johansson. But what if Johnasson would have take on the role of ruthless rebel Salander?

Thanks to But Like You're Really Pretty, we now at least know what it would look like if Johansson, Emma Watson, Kristen Stewart, Natalie Portman, Keira Knightley or Ellen Page would look like if they took on the role. Did Fincher make the right choice? Weigh in below!

[via But Like You're Really Pretty]