Album: David Archuleta

Play this song really low in your headphones in crowded places. But seriously, it's awesome. The pint-sized David Archuleta may not have won American Idol, but he made a hell of a song with "Crush." The love ballad which displays strong falsetto and a catchy chorus you'll probably sing in the shower was released in 2008, years before the re-emergence of the boy bands that we saw in 2012 with One Direction and The Wanted. "Crush" also debuted at number two on the Billboard 200-an impressive feat for someone who didn't even win American Idol.You're never #2 in our hearts, David. -Joe La Puma