We already knew that they were nauseated by food and an excellent debate duo, but did you also know that Steve Carell and Stephen Colbert were in a barbershop quartet together?

The duo—who started out together in Chicago with the famous Second City comedy troupe—along with Paul Dinello and David Razowksy perform a tune called “The Obvious Song,” which certainly has its moments but doesn’t seem quite as funny as the audience is making it out to be. To be fair, the VHS audio is not exactly top-quality, so maybe you can’t quite hear everything.

[via Vulture]