Our teenage selves freaked out when we heard Adam Brody and Leighton Meester were dating. Hello, Blair Waldorf and Seth Cohen? They actually know each other outside of starring in Josh Schwartz teen primetime soaps: They met on the set of 2011’s The Oranges and were friends before kicking it up a notch in January.

Yes, we’re still hoping he’ll get back together with soulmate Summer Roberts Rachel Bilson, but a relationship with Meester was a pleasant surprise. They’re also appearing together in next year’s Life Partners, with Community’s Gillian Jacobs and SNL’s Abby Elliot. Maybe Schwartz will make all our dreams come true and create a TV show just for Brody and Meester.