When it debuted: 2009
Segment lowlight: Drew Barrymore licks a Bowling Ball

Of the Fallon audience games, this has to be the worst. The lucky audience member (or celebrity) licks an object for 10 seconds and is paid $10. Here are Fallon writers at a Paley Center event, uncomfortably talking about their process of coming up with these games.

Look, we appreciate the passion for absurdity that the writers bring to their craft, but no one wants to watch people lick things for 10 seconds. Note that even a couple of the writers admit that the bit was one of the worst they ever did.